Manchester United could be heading for one of their biggest squad overhauls in recent history, with ESPN identifying 13 players who should leave Old Trafford as Mauricio Pochettino begins his new era at the club.
In a detailed squad assessment published on November 20, ESPN journalist Mark Ogden evaluated Manchester United’s first-team players and delivered his verdict on who should stay and who should go.
Perhaps most surprisingly, club captain Bruno Fernandes, academy graduate Marcus Rashford, Lisandro Martinez and Amad Diallo were all placed on the departure list.
However, these are ESPN’s editorial recommendations, not an official transfer list issued by Manchester United or Pochettino.
The 13 Manchester United players ESPN believes should leave
1. Bruno Fernandes
Despite describing Fernandes as United’s best player, ESPN believes the 32-year-old captain should be sold next summer. With the Portuguese midfielder approaching the later stages of his career, a transfer could generate significant funds for Pochettino to invest in younger players.
2. Marcus Rashford
ESPN questions whether Rashford possesses the work rate required to succeed under Pochettino. Although the England international remains dangerous with his pace and finishing, his reported £325,000 weekly wages are another major consideration.
3. Lisandro Martinez
Martinez’s injury history, inconsistent performances and approaching contract expiry have raised questions about his future. Despite sharing Argentine nationality with Pochettino, ESPN believes United should move on rather than offer the defender a new deal.
4. Amad Diallo
One of the more controversial selections, Amad has been criticised for his decision-making in attacking situations. ESPN acknowledges his ability to create opportunities but questions whether he can consistently deliver the performances required at the highest level.
5. Patrick Dorgu
Dorgu’s versatility has allowed him to operate across several positions on the left flank. However, ESPN argues that the Danish international has shown too few signs of developing into a reliable long-term option for Manchester United.
6. Andrey Santos
Signed for a reported £48 million in the summer, Santos has struggled to establish himself at Old Trafford. ESPN also highlights his previous spell under Pochettino at Chelsea, when he was sent out on loan, as a potential concern for his future.
7. Luke Shaw
Shaw’s recurring injury problems remain a major obstacle. Despite his previous connection with Pochettino at Southampton, ESPN believes United should allow the experienced left-back to leave when his contract expires at the end of the season.
8. Noussair Mazraoui
Although Mazraoui can operate in multiple defensive positions, ESPN questions whether he offers sufficient quality or reliability to remain part of United’s long-term plans.
9. Matthijs de Ligt
Injuries have significantly disrupted De Ligt’s Manchester United career. ESPN argues that his repeated absences make it difficult for Pochettino to depend on him as a central figure in the defence.
10. Mason Mount
Mount’s time at Old Trafford has been severely affected by fitness problems. ESPN points to his limited number of full Premier League appearances since arriving in 2023 and questions whether he can ever become a consistently available option.
11. Joshua Zirkzee
Despite showing improvement as a substitute in recent weeks, Zirkzee continues to face questions about his suitability for Premier League football. ESPN believes United should consider selling the Dutch forward if they can recover a substantial portion of his transfer fee.
12. Manuel Ugarte
ESPN has also recommended parting ways with Ugarte, citing concerns over his mobility, passing ability and overall suitability for the team. His serious knee injury sustained during the World Cup further complicates any potential departure.
13. Karl Darlow
The experienced goalkeeper completes the list. ESPN believes United need a higher-quality backup goalkeeper to compete with the Premier League’s strongest teams.
Who does ESPN believe Manchester United should keep?
Interestingly, ESPN’s assessment is far from entirely negative. Several players have been identified as important pieces for Pochettino’s rebuilding project.
Among those recommended to stay are:
- Diogo Dalot: His durability, commitment and versatility make him a valuable squad member.
- Harry Maguire: His leadership and experience could be useful during the transition.
- Leny Yoro: A young defender with the potential to become a key player under Pochettino.
- Kobbie Mainoo: A promising midfielder who could develop further under the new manager.
- Carlos Baleba: His energy and mobility could suit Pochettino’s playing philosophy.
- Matheus Cunha: His determination and ability to deliver important goals are valuable assets.
- Bryan Mbeumo: A proven Premier League attacker capable of rediscovering his best form.
- Benjamin Sesko: A young striker who deserves more time to develop.
Is a major Manchester United rebuild necessary?
The appointment of Mauricio Pochettino marks another attempt to restore Manchester United’s competitiveness after years of disappointing performances and managerial changes.
The Argentine coach is known for demanding intensity, discipline and commitment from his players. His preferred style requires a squad capable of pressing aggressively, covering significant distances and maintaining high physical standards.
However, selling 13 first-team players would represent an enormous challenge, particularly given the financial implications of existing contracts and the cost of finding suitable replacements.
It would also mean making some deeply unpopular decisions. Fernandes remains one of United’s most influential players, while Rashford and Amad still have supporters who believe they can contribute to the club’s future.
Whether Pochettino agrees with ESPN’s assessment remains to be seen. The new manager will have to evaluate his squad before deciding who deserves a place in his long-term plans.
What do you think? Should Manchester United really let all 13 players leave, or are there some names on this list who deserve another chance under Pochettino?


