Michael Carrick has made it clear that no Manchester United player is guaranteed a place in the starting XI, although he stressed that his comments were not a direct warning to Bruno Fernandes.
Carrick Says Even Bruno Fernandes Is Not Guaranteed a Starting Place at Man Utd
Michael Carrick has made it clear that no Manchester United player is guaranteed a place in his starting XI, including captain Bruno Fernandes.

The United boss was asked directly whether Bruno had become an “undroppable” player because of his importance to the team.
Carrick’s answer was clear.
“Nobody’s guaranteed a place in the team.”
However, he immediately added that his comments should not be presented as a direct attack on Bruno.
Carrick sends clear message to entire squad
Carrick explained that every Manchester United player must continue earning his place through performances and behaviour.
He said selection depends on several important factors, including form, attitude and understanding of what the team needs.

For Carrick, status and reputation alone are not enough to guarantee a starting position.
The message applies to the entire squad, from younger players to senior stars.
‘This is not on Bruno’
After making his point, Carrick quickly made sure his words were not misunderstood.
“This is not on Bruno… don’t use it for that,” he said.
The United manager wanted to make clear that he was not publicly warning or threatening his captain.
/origin-imgresizer.tntsports.io/2026/10/12/image-9fc23552-2f7e-40fb-9b9a-d4501288a843-85-2560-1440.jpeg)
Instead, he was explaining a general rule that applies to every player.
That means Bruno is not being singled out, even if his recent form has attracted more attention.
Why Bruno’s position is being questioned
The debate comes because Bruno has not been as dominant this season as he was during United’s strong run last year.
The Portugal international remains one of Carrick’s most trusted players and has continued to start regularly.

But his performances have been less consistent, leading to questions over whether he should still be considered an automatic starter.
That was the reason Carrick was asked directly about Bruno’s place in the team.
Bruno has also been carrying a fitness problem
There is another important factor behind Bruno’s recent performances.
Carrick confirmed that the midfielder has been playing with a minor physical problem.
He explained that players often continue playing even when they are not fully fit.
The positive news is that Carrick believes Bruno is now almost completely over the issue.
He also said the midfielder looked positive in training and was in a much better physical condition.
Carrick still has huge faith in Bruno
Despite saying that nobody is guaranteed a place, Carrick also strongly defended his captain.
He described Bruno as a top player and made it clear that he still expects him to produce important performances for United.

Carrick also said there is no real doubt that Bruno can return to the level he showed last season.
That is important because it shows the manager’s comments were not a sign that Bruno has suddenly lost his trust.
No special treatment at Man Utd
Carrick’s message is ultimately about competition inside the squad.
Every player must continue performing well enough to keep his place.
That includes Bruno, but it also includes every other senior player at the club.
The captain’s armband, experience and past performances do not automatically guarantee a starting role.
Pressure increases ahead of major games
The comments come at an important time for Manchester United.
The club is entering a demanding period and Carrick will need strong performances from his biggest players.

That means Bruno’s form will remain under close attention.
If his performances improve, there is little reason to believe he will lose his place. But Carrick has now made it clear that nobody is untouchable.
Carrick balances warning with support
The United manager’s message was firm but carefully balanced.
On one hand, he refused to give any player a guaranteed starting position.
On the other, he defended Bruno and warned against turning his comments into a personal attack on the captain.
The conclusion is simple: Bruno remains one of Manchester United’s most important players, but even he must continue earning his place.


